Shri Ekmukhi Datta MandirAvadhoot Chintan Shri Gurudev Datta

Gurucharitra › Chapter 25

Shri Gurucharitra – Chapter 25: The Challenge of Two Proud Brahmins

ॐImage coming soon
▶Video coming soon

Kand: Karma Kanda | Main characters: Shri Nrusinha Saraswati, Trivikram Bharati, two Brahmins proud of their learning, the Yavana king of Vidura (Bidar) | Place: Vidura (Bidar), Kumasi, Ganagapur

Background

With the Jnana Kanda complete, Siddhamuni begins telling Namdharak the Karma Kanda. The Karma Kanda discusses the Vedas, ritual action, conduct, vows and their fruits. It begins with a dramatic episode: two Brahmins full of pride in their learning, whose pride Shri Guru humbled in Chapters 25 to 27. These three chapters together form a single story.

The full story

The king who asked questions

They say learning makes a person humble. But what if that same learning falls into the hands of ego? This is the story of two such scholars.

In those days a Yavana king ruled in the city of Vidura (today's Bidar). The scripture describes him as cruel by nature. He had a strange hobby: he would call Brahmins to his court, make them recite the Vedas and ask them the meaning. Those who explained the meaning he honoured with wealth.

But behind this he also had a motive. He would say, "The Vedas say that Brahmins sacrifice animals in yajnas. Then what is wrong if I too kill animals?" Interpreting the Vedas to suit himself to justify violence was his game.

Two Brahmins proud of their Vedic learning

One day two Brahmins came to this king's court. They had studied the Vedas, were expert at memorisation and skilled in debate. But along with learning, a huge ego had entered their minds. "We know all four Vedas. There are no Vedic scholars like us," they would say proudly.

They displayed their learning before the king and demanded, "Maharaj, is there any scholar in your city who can debate with us? If there is, call him."

Silence spread through the court. The king looked curiously at the pandits of his court. No one in the city came forward. Some feared the debate, some feared the royal court; there was also the fear that if they lost, the king would be angry. In the king's court the standing of the two grew.

A bundle of jayapatras

Now they wanted more fame. They began wandering from village to village. Wherever they heard there was a scholar, they went and challenged him: "Debate with us on the Vedas, or give us a jayapatra (certificate of victory) written 'we are defeated'."

Many simple, peaceful Brahmins, not wanting to get into the trouble of a debate and afraid of the royal patronage behind the two, wrote out jayapatras. With every new jayapatra the pride of the two swelled further. The bundle of jayapatras in their bag was growing, and in their minds a mountain of ego.

In Kumasi: before Trivikram Bharati

Wandering on, they came to the village of Kumasi. They heard, "A great learned sannyasi named Trivikram Bharati lives here." Thinking, "If we get a jayapatra from him, our fame will grow even more," they went to him.

Without even greeting him, they said rudely, "We are knowers of all four Vedas. Debate with us, or write us a jayapatra admitting defeat."

This moment is very poignant. Only a few days earlier this same Trivikram Bharati had been criticising the ascetic of Ganagapur. Now, in that same Kumasi, two Brahmins had come to challenge his own learning. Had he been the old Trivikram, he might have accepted the challenge and convened an assembly for a scriptural debate. But now he had changed.

Only a few days earlier Trivikram Bharati had been humbled by Shri Guru's vision of the cosmic form. He said calmly, "I am a sannyasi. I have nothing to do with debate, victory or defeat."

But the Brahmins would not listen. They insisted again and again and put pressure on him. Finally Trivikram said, "If you are so insistent, my Guru is in Ganagapur. He is all-knowing. Come, put your challenge before him."

The two thought, "Another sannyasi. Another jayapatra." They set out for Ganagapur with Trivikram.

In the math at Ganagapur

The road from Kumasi to Ganagapur. In front walked Trivikram Bharati calmly, and behind him the two, whispering and laughing to each other. "This sannyasi is taking us to his Guru. So now we will get two jayapatras at once," they were calculating. They had no idea at whose door they were going.

As soon as they reached the math, Trivikram Bharati prostrated fully before Shri Guru and told him everything. The two Brahmins, however, stood stiffly.

Shri Guru looked at them calmly and asked, "Brahmins, we are sannyasis. What is victory or defeat to us? What will you gain by debating with us?"

They said proudly, "We have won everywhere. Look, we have many jayapatras. Now either you debate, or give us a jayapatra."

"Pride is the root of ruin"

There was compassion in Shri Guru's eyes; he could see the downfall ahead of these two. He said, "Listen. Whom has pride ever done good? King Bali was generous, but went down to the netherworld through ego. Banasura of a thousand arms was defeated by pride. A great scholar like Ravana was destroyed with his whole clan because of pride. The Kauravas' ego drowned them."

He went on, "And the Vedas? Even Brahma, the creator, does not fully know all the Vedas. Then how can you claim, after a little memorisation, 'we know all the Vedas'? Leave this path. Become humble. Otherwise you will only harm yourselves."

The disciples and villagers gathered in the math were stunned to hear these words. Shri Guru, whom the lord himself came to see, could calmly say to these rude Brahmins, "We have nothing to do with victory or defeat." This is the true mark of a sannyasi. This advice was given in love, as a warning. But the Brahmins, blinded by pride, did not understand it. "We do not want advice. We want a debate," they kept insisting.

Shri Guru then decided first to show them the true nature and vast extent of the Vedas, so that they themselves would see the hollowness of their claim. That explanation comes in the next chapter.

Lessons

Interesting details

Link to the next chapter

In the next chapter Shri Guru explains to the Brahmins the vast extent of the Vedas and shows how hollow their claim "we know all the Vedas" is.

Shri Ekmukhi Datta Mandir